Showing posts with label sitrep digests. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sitrep digests. Show all posts

Sunday, March 23, 2025

Sitreps 6 and 7!

Goodness but I've been neglectful. I've read your sitreps faithfully, but I've not posted a digest. My apologies. If I'm honest with myself, I think part of me has avoided digest-ing all your reflections because a lot of the material we've covered and discussions we've had have grappled with some dicey, difficult, even intractable conflicts inherent in the discussion of canon and pedagogy. It's tense! There's the "I hate conflict" part of myself that's particularly noisy since I'm burning so much psychic energy fending off The Awfulness and getting through each day (I'm sure we can all relate). 

That said, any kind of grappling worthy of the name involves tension and conflict (and pleasure!). Thus we dive in:

Marina shares some hard, honest truths:

Between this class and this book [Latinx Actor Training], I realize how much I have been denied the space to learn about acting and theatre in reference to where I come from. I know I look white, but I have a desire to study and create art that resonates with where I come from. I think I have done myself a disservice relying on Predominately White Institutions to teach me. I am jealous of my friends who are at places like Northwestern or Brown, where explaining their latinidad is not something they are asked to do. In Austin, working among non-white artists, it was never up for debate if I was “latina” enough. I just am. But coming here, I have had professors try to gaslight me into thinking that no one would hire me to be in plays written by Jose Rivera. I am pissed. Mad that I have allowed myself to be subjected to educators who are so ignorant. Granted that is not my experience with professors here overall. But, one bad professor can really fuck with your sense of self. I feel that I was asked to pick a side, and the side they implied was white. What does this have to do with class? I guess my point is that the syllabus we decide to teach has great impact on our students. What we choose to include and exclude impacts how students see and value their stories. As I reach the end of my time here at LSU, I am learning a lot about what not to do as a professor. I am also discovering the professor I want to be. 

Heard. It is an unfortunate truth that we often learn what kind of professor we want to be thanks to some painful experiences with the kind of professor we don't want to be. 

Ricardo echoes some of Marina's frustrations, though from a different angle (and with a shout-out to Marina's good help and advice):

In [the poem he shares], I’m trying to conceive of a way where I could view myself in the way that others view me, without being weighed down by the shackles of being in my own body. The plays we read last week really ignited this line of thinking in me because they all had to do with the latino identity in one way or another. If you know me, then you know that I was born and raised in Puerto Rico for all my life until college. Like any boricua, I carry a huge sense of pride being from the island. This immense sense of pride imbues how I perform and interact with others on and off stage. But at points in my life I’ve found it hard to belong. I have a distinct memory of when I was in middle school. During the summer I was attending a YMCA basketball camp and I had a feeling that I didn’t quite belong. I’ve been very proficient at English my entire life (because I used to watch a lot of Cartoon Network.) I’m also very pale. These two facts would make the kids at the camp call me “gringo” which is puertorican slang for american. I remember driving back with my dad and telling him in the car “I’m Puertorican, but I’m not that Puertorican.” Meaning that my identity was lessened because of the color of my skin and how I acted. My father quickly disregarded this by saying “You are Puertorican, just as much as anybody else.” This is a statement I go back to a lot when I start having problems with my own identity. That being said, having a sort of loose identity does help me with my acting. In my time here I’ve played an aging father from Pennsylvania, a Southern tech billionaire, a megalomaniac boss man, a Prussian stagehand and a British actor. I am none of these things, but it hasn’t been particularly hard to slip into their mindsets due to the fluidity of my identity. This has its positives, but I really felt the negatives reading the assigned scripts this week. I love Jesus Hopped the A Train, I love it so much it was one of the few shows I submitted for consideration for next year’s season, but upon re-reading it I had a realization. I can’t see myself playing the main character, Angel, even though he is Puerto Rican. Angel talks like how I talk with my friends back home, we struggle with the same issues of faith and what is right, but I just can’t imagine myself being cast in the role because I’m too pale. I mentioned this viewpoint in class and people agreed. Marina (who is also a paler Puerto Rican) gave me some comforting words after the lesson.  

(I suspect Marina is already the kind of teacher/mentor/peer that sets her apart from the negative examples she talks about.) I want also, Ricardo, to acknowledge that your feelings are real and understandable. When you shared that originally in class, I made a joke in class (as is my wont). I regret it now and apologize. That frustration is legitimate. As Marina notes, there are plenty of unhelpful-but-influential voices murmuring about what parts you might be allowed to play due to not looking (to white people, in the opinion of that one white person) as authentic as you know yourself to be. You get to acknowledge those voices and name how annoying they are without anyone poking fun at you about it. You also get to decide otherwise than those voices, hopefully surrounded by peers who know who you are and affirm that.

Sarah shares some cogent thoughts on why so many works by non-Anglo-European/non-Western playwrights appear as adaptations of Western canonical works (e.g., The Hungry Woman):

Although adaptations can be used by artists from minoritized groups as a way to break into the industry, these works tend to gain relevance due to their familiarity to the source material. As Marina mentioned, the only way to read these works within the Western academy, and to make them legible to an audience on the steady diet of the Western canon, is to hold them hand in hand with the canon itself. More often than not, the result is a re-centering of the canon, rather than a departure from it.

However, during the early days of the class, we spoke about how departures from canons are often stepping stones for the creation of new ones. Canons are one of the ways through which society organises it's cultural heritage, and this organisation is predicated on distributions of power which dictate how the canon functions, arming it with the authority to categorise and create hierarchies. Because hierarchies comprise so much of society's fabric, it can be difficult to depart from a canon without establishing a replacement in the resultant power vacuum. In this regard, I think adaptations function as a pressure-release valve, permitting motion within, and exchanges across the levels of the hierarchy in order to prevent the entire structure from toppling. Within these exchanges, there is an opportunity for adaptations to exercise critical engagements which pierce through the canon to the power structures behind them. The Hungry Woman is a great example of this, as it utilises different devices to engage with (among other things) American Exceptionalism and its effects on legacy of genocide within its borders, and the perceived threats of terrorism without.

I love that notion of adaptations as pressure-release valves.

Barrett (in his sitrep 6), reflects on why Ybarra's article on teaching Latinx plays resonates: 

Reconsidering her article now, I’m thinking about the specific content of the article, but also why it feels particularly effective or relatable to me personally when so many articles introduce me to an idea that I feel receptively distanced from – often the articles I read contain an idea/ideas that I can intellectually consider but am left feeling like I don’t have enough framework, ability, or experience with which to fully engage. This has me thinking more critically about audience reception in a pedagogical sense. 

Andrew reflects on a different sort of appeal (and a different sort of adaptation) in a post about The King and I, noting first how striking it is that so much commentary about the play (and cultural spinoffs from the play) concentrate on Yul Brenner's physical attractiveness. That appeal, Andrew notes, often swamps other considerations: 

This mass appeal, or this rhetorical notion of serving for mass appeal, is one of the reasons why changes towards this story, or even plays like Miss Saigon, might not stand the test of time. The reason is because of the need to make the words legible, the language of colonization and the customs of "legibility" inform what the characters ultimately do. The entire play, the characters play the game of "hey that thing you do is weird and it makes you weird" constantly. Only through learning about the person do the characters consider things in a different dynamic from weirdness. Its the equivalent of "I'm not racist, I know ___". 

In terms of personal appeal, Emmy notes how much she loved Water by the Spoonful. I love how she uses her pleasure to do a bit of deep dive into the structure of the text. (Come share this with my script analysis students, Emmy!):  

I genuinely enjoyed reading this script. There’s so many references to music: whether it be music theory, artists, songs, histories, genres (such as jazz)--I couldn't help but to immerse myself by playing the chords/songs mentioned, which really added an entirely new dimension to my understanding of the story. An important concept that I picked up on was one of dissonance: which means “lack of harmony among musical notes”, but it can also mean “a tension or clash resulting from the combination of two disharmonious or unsuitable elements.” When thinking in terms of this play, dissonance was found in many characters– Elliot as a civilian suffering from PTSD from his time in the service (which is shown by the repeated line: Momken men-fadluck ten-dini gawaz saffari which means, "Can I please have my passport back?"), Haikumom’s personality/behavior versus Odessa’s (who are actually the same person), and Fountainhead/John’s life as an addict versus his life as a husband. As far as canonicity goes, I think the script from this play says it best: “change the syllabus.

I love how that sense of pleasure fuels your careful work, Emmy. (See also Emmy's very useful breakdown of the differences between the old and new West Side Story films. I love a table! Good work, Emmy.) 

A bit of productive tension between perspectives emerges when it comes to the KPOP show--its relatively short run compared to the popularity of a revival of a much more problematic musical like The King and I. Craig weighs in:

 While I do not plan to use this writing to run down The King and I it would be dishonest to leave out the fact that watching the show was a bit of a slog for me. The article "Decompression in the King and I and KPOP" brought many of these frustrations to light. Learning about the disregard for accurate Thai dialects, and the ignoring of Thai cultural traditions in order to appeal to White audiences was insulting and frustrating to read. It makes me wonder if the King and I is a show that should be put on the shelf. The other concern is the thought that in order for there to be mainstream cultural penetration a work by a BIPOC or woman artist must pass through the lens of whiteness. KPOP's short Broadway run while King and I's revival wildly succeeded is a hard pill to swallow. It begs the question of why when it is time for authentic cultural representation there is always something in the way that handicaps that representation. Be it the pandemic, claims of not finding audiences, there is always an excuse for why accurate cultural representation cannot happen. 

Barrett pushes back, not against Craig but--gently--against Kim's argument (or lack thereof) regarding KPOP's failure to find Broadway success:

At the very least, her disappointment at its early closure is palpable, though she does very little to explore why it closed. Only at the very end of the article, and only in a footnote lamenting the choice of the show’s title and by extension implicating the show’s marketing choices as misleading (168), does she explore any other reason for the show’s closure then systemic racism. It’s certainly plausible that this was a cause, or even the cause, but not exploring other possibilities is problematic for a few reasons. First, it allows those who might be responsible or complicit in perpetuating systemic issues in the Broadway ecosystem (audiences and producers alike) to look for other reasons that the show closed and, after finding them, summarily dismiss the bigger problems Kim is attempting to highlight. Secondly, she creates an implicit demand that productions who advocate for and demonstrate social justice in their processes should be exempt from theatrical criticism, not to mention the normal strictures of Broadway production – namely that the show has wide enough commercial appeal (and quality?) to make its producers money, which, if racism was the reason for the show’s closure, would implicate audiences as much as it does the producers or Jesse Green.  In her opening paragraph, Kim points out KPop’s boundary-breaking feats, thus equating a litany of firsts with qualification for belonging to the Broadway oeuvre. She then doubles down on this assertion by explaining that mediocrity signifies privileged status (168), closing off discussion of any kind of theatrical qualification such as, I don’t know, say…story? Criticisms made in other reviews (https://newyorktheater.me/2022/11/27/kpop-on-broadway-review/)? Production elements? Or more broadly speaking, what constitutes theatre? What should? How did the constraints of the Broadway stage hurt the successful form of the immersive off-Broadway production?  

Were this class more focused on musical theatre, we might focus even more attention on Allegiance. That show seems like a clearer example of a production that, although boasting many representational firsts, seems in the eyes of most (even very supportive critics) not to be the world's best piece of musical theatre. It is, stylistically, much closer to King and I than the quasi-avant-garde KPOP: more legible and comparable to "mainstream"--and it suffers from that comparison. 

Perhaps two things are true at once: (1) judgments of quality (is it good?) are inevitably inflected by various privilege systems and not wholly original, and (2) at some point, some kind of conversation about quality does play a role even in productions that explicitly call out and resist those privilege systems. Here a model like David Roman's "critical generosity" ought to come in--applying context-specific standards of importance/quality/success for culturally specific artworks while still insisting that those questions can and should play a role. 

I think Craig practices something like this critical generosity--but toward the dominant culture of the Rodgers and Hammerstein 1950s--in his next sitrep: 

When looking at The King and I, despite my extreme offense at the way it depicted Thai culture I was actually compelled by the structure of the piece as a play. Oscar Hammerstein, while misguided in his approach to the story does manage to craft a story about a transfer of power between the generations in Siam that is actually thought provoking. Hear me out! The issue with the show's depiction of Western Culture's influence on Siam is grossly inaccurate, but that influence being conveyed through a father passing down power to a son, and the youth changing the country is an interestingly radical conception for the era in which the show was written. While the show is one that I would put on the shelf in terms of producing it again, I do think it's important to know and understand what Hammerstein was reaching for, even if he didn't achieve it. The way the musical's form actually manages to weave scene and song together to build up to its ending is dramaturgically compelling, if deeply flawed.

Truth: one of my favorite class moments so far was when Ricardo burst in to our discussion about those problem musicals. We'd been absolutely trashing "classic" musicals that nevertheless feature white culture (mis)representing marginalized ethnic groups, e.g., The King and I and West Side Story. Marina summarizes this criticism well (and, FWIW, captures my thoughts about it):  

My big question is: why keep producing these plays that were not written by or for the communities represented for the sake of “representation", when there are capable artists who are from these communities and want to tell their stories? My hunch is that these “classics” stick around because of nostalgia. Also, producers are banking on the built in fan base to sell tickets. . . . within the context of the time when they were first produced they were groundbreaking and imperfect. But, we know better now. SO, we deserve better. I think if I were to include a musical like West Side Story into my syllabus I would want to counter it with something that demonstrates a culturally conscious musical. For instance, Buena Vista Social Club just opened on Broadway.

I think we were all basically on the same page at that point. And then Ricardo bursts in and shared just how much his family adored the original West Side Story. In his words:  

Something can be ugly and wrong but if it’s us, it’s us. To be visible especially at the point in time was huge and i dont doubt that the portrayal of Puerto Rican people on screen in a film that big had some effect on how much Puerto Rican culture is in the mainstream nowadays from regueton to Hollywood. To be seen is to exist.

There's a whole class about the ways that identity politics are predicated on a politics of visibility. One of the classic go-to texts here would be Peggy Phelan's Unmarked: The Politics of Performance from 1999. She examines the pros and cons of visibility in our mass-mediated culture. On the one hand, visibility matters (I see myself/us!). On the other hand, visibility summons surveillance and control (We're watching you). As she memorably quips (I paraphrase), if visibility were really power, then scantily clad young white women would be running the world.

And yet: To be seen is to exist remains true. 

Thanks for writing and thinking, y'all!

Tuesday, February 25, 2025

Sitrep Digest 5!

Let's start with Andrew, who picks up on Colbert's commentary on Wine in the Wilderness and links (intersects?) it with Kemberle Crenshaw's work:

We  see in the play how much class distinctions is intentional made early on. According to Colbert (2009), "In teaching this play, I direct my students’ attention to how the characters’ language suggests their class positioning. I question how Bill’s class-inflected speech differs and aligns with Tommy’s categorization of her neighbors. I alert students to the fact that Tommy’s use of the pejorative separates her from the rioters and establishes her behavior as one of the several demarcations of class differences within the play. While most readings of Wine in the Wilderness, including La Vinia Delois Jennings’s account in Alice Childress, consider the ways Tommy forces Bill, Sonny-Man, and Cynthia to acknowledge their class privilege, critics do not consider Tommy’s assertions of superiority, which reveal a third class at play—the rioters. Moreover, since Riot Sale and The Bronx Is Next depict characters participating in or planning a riot, these plays do not establish the layers of divisions presented in Childress’s."

This line of thinking marks similar will Kimberlee Crenshaws paper, "Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color", we see how in pushing one side of a left leaning argument, it fails towards liberation for all and more aligns closely with liberation for all with caveats. Liberation is impeded not only by those how those traditionally in power resists and demand the status quo preserved, but it is also impeded at times by those trying to do revolutionary work. This is colonial though process makes it difficult for for consolidation. The play, as Colbert demonstrates, shows divisions among seemingly similar groups of people because of colonial Eurocentric views about mobility, and even notions of freedom and liberation.

Plays like this help demonstrate better the widening gap in groups that are labeled as "monolithic", because the classist nature of some in the group positions themselves as being the ones to pull up the rest of their ethnic group, while the the other gets the arm dragged and forced to be something they don't want to be. The play demonstrates this well in this and any community that seems divided amongst themselves, mainly because class is always obfuscated. Made hard to see. That way when a person like Tommy comes into a scene, we can blame their life being the way it is as "her fault", or show some kind of self-aggrandizing pity without actively changing anything about our own lives to make hers marginally better.


Echoing some of these themes--how certain strands of liberatory rhetoric work by suppressing other strands--Sarah gives us a banger of a post with some some trenchant questions about other kinds of suppressed rhetorics (and identities):

Towards the end of the play, Tommy has a phenomenal moment in the sun: raging against Bill, Old Timer, Sonny-Man, and Cynthia, she demonstrates the deep seated self-loathing at the heart of their progressive ethos. She strikes them in the same way that a mother would - with accuracy, care, and the intent to build up. While she calls them out for the way they abused her trust and misaligned her character, she also opens their eyes to reality of their societal position, demonstrating the ways in which the superiority they claimed was only functioning to reinforce the very negative stereotypes they were trying to escape. 

But right at the moment of Tommy's triumph, something strange occurs. She opens Bill's eyes to his rather misogynistic view of black women, showing that her living, breathing, existence was so much more than one simple swipe on a canvas. At this moment, Bill comes to the realisation that Tommy is right, and he promptly takes control of the reigns. Just as Tommy is about to triumphantly exit the space and leave the group to their collective shame, Bill pipes up and begins to wax poetic. The very first thing that he does is reorient the identities of the people around him - identities which, up until this point, were depicted as being inferior to his masculine, nationalistic, virile, artistic prowess. First, he reinforces Old Timer by using his real name (a name he was not aware of prior to Tommy's arrival). He then confronts Cynthia with the truth of her beauty, and makes an interesting rhetorical gesture by immediately linking it with Sonny-Man's masculinity. Tommy's exit is interrupted by Bill's apparent enlightenment, and the woman who was adamantly against posing in a mis-matched outfit is convinced to pose, holding the wig that was initially so abhorrent to Bill. The final line of the show (like the first one), is given to Bill, who engages in the artistic practise of composing a black female identity that is bolstered by an appeased black masculinity. 

This is worth at least a conference paper, Sarah, if not a (part of) an article. You'd want to do some more poking around to see if someone else has noted this as well (Colbert would be a good place to start, I think). But yes: great. 

And I appreciate Craig fighting through the after-show fog to comment thoughtfully on last week's readings:

Alice Childress' Wine in the Wilderness, got me really excited to examine the way that Blackness, particularly Black Femininity, is presented in theatre. The battle for Blackness and its representation on stage is one that is obviously compelling for me. When thinking about how to help students engage with works by Black artists I think it is imperative that we try to remind students that the culture is not monolithic and contains just as much variance as any other. Setting Raisin and Wine against each other, in terms of comparison, is a good step in the right direction because of the combination of works. I'm very interested in pedagogy that puts plays in comparison with one another to understand a canonical work, and another lesser known work from the period. In an undergraduate classroom I am concerned with the amount of bandwidth that students will have to read so many works in order to accomplish the curriculum. Even as a Graduate student I am finding the reading difficult to keep up with among my other responsibilities. So the question is how can we get students to engage with multiple works while not burning them out?

I hear (and echo!) Craig's crowded-bandwidth feelings. Realize how stressed you are reading plays for this class (let alone plays and articles). Mark that level of stress--and our inevitable reactions to stress (i.e., skimming, not reading and just feeling really guilty, promising ourselves we'll read them later, etc.). Let that inform your own decisions as you start thinking about the first syllabus you'll put together and present (on Wednesday, March 19!). Less really is more. But! Comparing two plays is super-valuable! What to do?

Emmy steers us back to Raisin in the Sun in the first part of her post:

Interesting to compare it to communism, marxism, ect, because that’s the last thing I would expect in reference to an analysis of this play. I would expect, however, conversations based around racial and gender inequality. . . but the more I think about it (and think about the definition of communism– EQUALITY) the more I realize it’s not so crazy of an idea to look at this story through this particular lens. 

But in thinking through the lens of communism and equality, it was extremely unfair in Beneatha’s circumstance wherein she lost all of her money for med school. Where is the justice for her? Running off to Africa with Asagai?

You know what, Emmy? You're right: Hansberry is so focused on Walter's deferred dream that she gives short shrift to Beneatha and her dream. When does Beneatha get her own play? I bet it's been done. There's even a whole anthology about plays based on or spinning off from Raisin. [Quick duckduckgo-ing] Bingo! Beneatha's Place by Kwame Kwei-Armah. (Production poster to the left) I don't know how to get a copy. Perhaps you could write him and ask!


 

Speaking of which: Ricardo builds on his presentation about TikTok to affirm another affordance of social mediatized culture: reciprocity between artists and audiences:

In the presentation I made on Wednesday’s class I talked about social media’s (more specifically, tiktok’s) ability to reach out to younger audiences and find more people to fill up seats, but what I didn’t touch upon was the inverse effect of all these shows and people having a social media presence. People you admire are easier to reach out now than they ever were, before you would have to write them a letter and hope they would get back to you, but nowadays you can just send them a silly little text on the device you’re already on for most of your day. I have used this to my advantage. Most of the time, playwrights are very willing to share their work that isn’t readily available if you just ask nicely. A couple months ago, I saw that Playwright Horizons was putting on a show titled In the Amazon Warehouse Parking Lot. I knew nothing about this play, other than the title and a short trailer posted on their Youtube channel, but I couldn’t help how badly I wanted to read it. I looked it up online to see if I could purchase it anywhere, but I was out of luck. Parking Lot is still in production and hasn’t reached its final version just yet. I thought that would be it, until the thought came to mind to follow and message the playwright. I just messaged Sarah Mantell “Hi, I love reading plays and I really wanted to read In the Amazon Warehouse Parking Lot. How can I find it?” She responded within two days with her personal email and shared the most updated version of the script with me. It was awesome. I’ve been doing this for some time now. Whenever I can’t find a play I’ll follow the writer on social media and just message them. I haven’t been ignored once, playwrights really want to share their work and if you show them how much you appreciate it they’ll be very happy to share.

 Marina gives a great overview of all the work from last week (I confess I had forgotten that Polanski directed the movie adaptation of Death and the Maiden). Here she weighs in on the social media reciprocity referenced above:

I’m Gonna Marry You, Toby Maguire was a fun read! I am intrigued by the similacrum play. If I was going to put this play in my syllabi, I would want to include an article to help students understand what Hurley is doing. I am still wrapping my brain around what Hurley is doing. Also, I think Ricardo connections to social media and engagement are interesting. Working in the Swine Palace office, I have little bandwidth or curiosity to strategize impactful social media campaigns. I was hoping I would learn from someone, but it is a fend for yourself kinda vibe. Theatre is hurting for audiences, and I think many companies focus their efforts on how to get “subscribers” aka senior citizens back. But, if theatre wants to stay relevant, we need to pay attention to what gets young people excited about coming to the theatre.

But, as Barrett explores in his post, promising social media affordances do not come without price. Here he writes about "cashing in on FOMO":

The second phrase that was spoken in class and stuck out to me this week, is perhaps the flip side of social media. In the rush to be on trend and capitalize on markets that others are successfully exploiting, I do wonder about the ethics of “cashing in on FOMO.” It’s now pretty widely known that social media is creating addicts and at least contributing to such serious mental health issues like anxiety, anti-social behaviors, and even suicide (see here: NIH). Before we anoint the next generation of TikTok Dramaturgs, should we at least ask the question if “cashing on FOMO” is aligned with any kind of personal or company values? Thomas Davenport and Jeanne Harris in their article “What People Want (And How to Predict It)” state what we all know to be true about human behavior: “As soon as it’s clear that money can be made using these…tools, their use will undoubtedly grow despite some observers’ moral and ethical qualms.” Yet much of the discussion we’ve been having as a class - care of actors, care of students, what to teach, what kinds of representation should be included in our canon – these are ethical and moral conversations. Anecdotally, I feel like the variety and frequency of ethical discussions in theatrical praxis has risen greatly since I’ve been a practicing theatre maker. Perhaps because of that when Ricardo described TikTok as having the most successful social media algorithm to keep folks scrolling and lose track of time, it gave me pause. How fast, I wonder, should theatre producers be rushing to “cash in” on people’s addictions? Is there a moral conversation to be had here about what this kind of marketing is doing to our potential customers, or if one were so inclined to view them more personally, our community members? 

(The Hnath play you reference sounds fabulous, Barrett.)

As always, everyone, excellent posts. 

Now I'm off to speed-re-read Guirgis and Ybarra (and first-time-read the article about Guirgis) for tomorrow's class. After all, I would hate to listen to a stimulating conversation and feel . . . FOMO.

Tuesday, February 18, 2025

Sitrep Digest 4!

 Another cool round of posts! Let's dive in to a digest:

Barrett starts us off with the good questions (well, with Craig's good question, to be clear):

In our class discussion on Wednesday about the efficacy of shock, Craig asked how we might communicate the impact that a production such as Blasted had on its original audience when examining the play in a contemporary classroom. To paraphrase, how does one historicize ‘that-which-was-shocking’ in a contemporary theatre course?  . . .It is always one thing to simply tell a student that something was shocking, convention-breaking, unsettling, and important to the historical evolution of theatre. It is a different matter altogether to get them to experientially comprehend this. At least part of the answer relates to an instructor’s particular ethics of care for their students when bringing shock into the classroom. The instructor must know to what degree they want students to have this kind of experiential knowledge, why that is important, how the relative maturity-level of the student impacts exploration of the course material, and how they will care for the students who might feel especially disoriented by the experience, and how they might temper the student who revels in the titillating nature of the experience but forgoes appropriate mental reflection. Without having some awareness of these factors, the instructor might inadvertently create an unsafe or chaotic instructional space where students are simply left to their own devices, much in the same way that actors are often not given the tools to de-role after a heightened emotional experience.

Andrew picks up on the theme, talking about in-yer-face theatre (it's "in-YER-face," not "in-YUR-face"--I should have made that clearer).

How can we teach an audience, when the audience want to be protected? They wanted to be like the "cameraman" meme. Believing that because they caught the action that they are shielded from the action. As if they are exempt from the affect. As if the performer is exempt from interaction. There's an implied museum-esque quality to the interaction. Separation, distinction, dismemberment, than In-Yur-Face theatre tries to disembowel. So it's not as hard as my impression was at the start of last week. More of a realization that we are all trying to do things differently so that we can teach/learn things differently.  

Emmy hits on several cool ideas related to shock, disorientation, and sex (sometimes all at once!). Lemme break down a few:

  • She talks about the shock of sex and sex work in performance (very apparent in many of the texts we discussed last week). This is a rich conversation. Some jumping-off points for discussing sex in performance (just a few, of course--there's a ton) would include Annie Sprinkle (sex-positive performance art from the 90s and beyond), Ron Athey (queer performance artist who blends sexually explicit work with meditations on his former evangelical-Pentecostal childhood faith), and Ann Liv Young (disturbing/confusing work in which explicit and sexual bodies [esp. her own] are central elements). See also work by (the tragically late) Jessica Burson, such as The Naked Result: How Exotic Dance Became Big Business. Several scholars have also written about Coyote (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics), a collective of sex workers and former sex workers.
  • Intentional abstraction and ambiguity in performance: About Blasted, she asks,"Why is Cate there in the hotel room? Why does she sleep with Ian? Was she part of the reason why the soldier came? Why does the soldier piss on the bed??? I feel like questions like these could be answered with an artist statement, but do playwrights do artist statements?" Consider that ambiguity is a calibrated choice by playwrights (and performance artists for that matter). They could have explained things fully; they choose not to. What effect does this ambiguity have, especially when contrasted with the explicit hyper-specificity of the violence and language on stage? 
  • Finally, Emmy requests we make some time to talk about Harris's Slave Play. I'm gonna do the annoying teacher thing and turn the request around: You make us talk about it, Emmy! Consider making that your "buried treasure" presentation. (You don't have to, of course.)

Craig--bless you for posting at all after your marathon of performances (in a marathon of a role)--admits to some distance from Belle Reprieve:

In terms of Belle Reprieve, I will admit to having a hard time following or understanding the piece. Not because of the play lacking merit or narrative interest, but simply through a combination of fatigue, note the aforementioned Red Velvet, and the play being a new experience for me. Once we watched the video I could start to understand the piece as performance in a way that I was not comprehending it as a text. It is in this area that I will admit that I lack a full understanding of queer culture and as a cis-gendered heterosexual man I have to try to be open to art that comes from a culture that is not my own. In some ways my lack of understanding in this area makes me deeply uncomfortable, not out of any negative association with queer culture or art, but the concern that my lack of understanding puts me at odds with what is being presented. I never want to dismiss a work because it does not connect to my particular perspective, I just want to take note of when my perspective makes it harder for me to understand.

Honestly, I think queer youngsters today would have as hard a time getting a lot of 80s/90s-style gay/lesbian camp. And I agree about the article: the valuable part was not the theory but the implementation and "here's what worked in my classroom" segments. This poses a related question to shock. How do we deal with students' confusion or boredom (which often emerges as a defense mechanism to confusion)? How do we make "I have no idea what that was" disorientation OK as an initial reaction?

Marina praises and echoes Barrett's thoughts about teaching shock-pieces such as in-yer-face (or others like Slave Play, for that matter):

I appreciated Barrett’s Keystone on In Yer Face Theatre. I had heard of Sarah Kane, but I had not read any of her plays. I would like to read them all. I think In Yer Face conventions may start being used again in light of our current administration. As we discussed in class, the in yer face tactics must be employed mindfully. Also, with suitability warnings, I wonder how those warnings influence the impact of In Yer Face shows. I am curious about how someone would go about teaching these plays to undergraduate students.

This worry seems resonant (though not identical to) the conversation we had about plays that use the n-word or other such slurs centrally and intentionally.  Is it a betrayal of Bullins to asterisk out the n-word in his play title? What kind of content warning could you give a play like Blasted or 4.48 Psychosis? (Is it any more than you'd give for a play like King Lear?) Does the very idea of content warning run counter to the spirit of in-yer-face? (Also, unrelated, I love Marina's ever-growing list!)

Sarah orients us to the relationship between spectacularized suffering (be in in Blasted or The Passion of the Christ) and personal (super-human) suffering:

In Maranatha, an article published by Josh Gunn, the author systematically examines the ways in which the body of Jesus in the 2004 film The Passion of the Christ is carved up by the director, the camera, and the audience for a viewing pleasure that is masosadist in nature, by employing elements in the pornographic genre through bodily affect. Near the start of the essay, Gunn notes that "The primary way in which Gibson butches up Jesus is through the depiction of a superhuman endurance of unbearable torture." 

To borrow the term 'superhuman' from this phrase, I think that the plays of Sarah Kane and other playwrights to employ violence of speech, and of the body engage with the audience by making them feel 'super-human' - not in the sense of a superhero, but through an inescapable confrontation with the corporeal and emotional limits of humanity. If this same lens is pointed towards Kane as an artist, through her death, it is possible that her persona has taken on a superhuman quality in the sense of escape - she is so close that we can hear her in her words, but eternally removed from us by way of having crossed the life barrier. In life, her suffering depicted a humanity that she has managed to escape and supersede in death, in the same way that Kurt Cobain and Amy Winehouse have. There is something infinitesimally cherish-able about suffering for art, but that very unnamable thing is what makes it unbearable. To look away is to deny the opportunity to be superhuman, but to stay is to witness irreversible death.

Food for thought as we turn to Wednesday's class with two very different portrayals of suffering and its effects.

 

Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Sitrep Post 3

 As always, it's a pleasure to read your thoughts on our prior week. I encourage you all to peruse each others' blogs when you can.

To whet your appetites, here's you weekly digest:

Barrett shares his thoughts on ethical, care-based actor training. Having taught acting in a conservatory environment for several years, he knows whereof he speaks, and he says it well:

To treat emotion work like any other facet of acting training, the topic of emotion needs to be further demystified. This starts by acknowledging exactly what is likely to happen to the actor when working with emotion, what the norms of experience are for actors during this part of the training, what constitutes a healthy and unhealthy range of experiences that one might have as they participate in this work, and offering a series of ways for students to process, discuss, and seek help with their experiences as they occur. Central in this discussion is an explanation of how emotions work, and crucially, why they matter in acting. Magelssen’s article stresses only one aim for emotional work, and while it is true that utilizing lived emotions contributes to the overall truthfulness of realistic performance, isolating emotions in acting training for the goal of “being more real” is an incomplete, and as the article makes clear, dangerous pedagogical practice. Emotions in acting should never be sought as an end result. Magelssen unfortunately neglects to point out that 21st-century students are generally called upon to perform objective-based work, and that emotions are useful because they are motivators of human action. Acting pedagogy cultivates students’ ability to access a wide range of emotion in order to further their ability to take action in a truthful manner. Emotions are simply an engine to drive behavior, which is the ultimate aim of the realistic actor. Any other use of emotion is self-indulgent, resulting in anti-dramatic work in the Aristotelian sense. Possessing this knowledge empowers actors to gauge their performance not on the strength of their overall emotional largesse. It allows them to regulate the use of emotion in performance by comparing it to what is essential at any given moment to achieve their truthful expression of an objective.

 If you're anything like me, I bet you find yourself a bit envious of Barrett's acting students. Barrett--were you yourself taught acting this way? Or did you find a better way than you were taught?

I love how Craig opens himself to surprise and curiosity by engaging Streetcar after years of resisting it (we all have plays/works/books we resist for some reason): 

I was surprised to discover that the play was about Blanche trying to find agency rather than being a portrait of Stanley Kowalski as an abuser. Stanley's abusiveness is apart of the puzzle, but not the sole focus of the piece. This discovery has led me to question why the play and subsequent Elia Kazan film are so remembered for Stanley and for Brando's performance as opposed to being remembered as a story about a woman trying to find agency and being held back by a patriarchal society. Critically it seems that the play is remembered for Brando's performance to the point that Blanche's story is forgotten. This is a moment where, similarly to our reading of 'night mother it seems that critical consensus missed the seeming intentions of Williams' text. The play was overwhelmed by the performance text created by Kazan, Brando, and the original cast.

One of the best things that can happen in a class like this (or any class), I think, is for us to be surprised out of our preconceptions about things we think we know. I really appreciate your sharing this, Craig.

Marina gives us an excellent example of a pedagogy of care done well:

Before I came to LSU, I taught for many years as a Teaching Artist. I received countless hours of training in Theatre of the Oppressed techniques/exercises, non-violent communication, and student-centered practices. In our pedagogy class at LSU, we did not receive any training in these areas. So, it appears to me that the ethics of care is not a priority at LSU. Or, it is only a priority for certain professors. In turn, students are receiving an “imbalance of care.” As a teaching artist, I always started my semester by asking students to come up with their community agreements. This practice was important for students to be invested in the entire groups well-being and progress. Since teaching here, I have abandoned that practice in exchange for a syllabus. A syllabus that I alone create. I have been operating this way because it is what was modeled for me. But after reading this article, I am recognizing I want to bring more of my teaching artist self into academic classes. For instance, I am in Kyla’s mask making class. For our first two days of class, she opened the floor for students to shape the syllabus and community agreements. I did not know I could do that. There were some non-negotiables, but she communicated why they were necessary.

Kyla Kazuschyk, for the record, is one of our best teachers. Your reflection, Marina, reminded me of the care article's quote about "care" consisting of "uncoerced choice" (or something like that). Kyla's open-syllabus assignment models that well.

In light of the violence in--well, all the plays we've read so far (especially this week), Andrew asks some provocative questions:

From A Street Car Named Desire to Belle Reprieve, or the violence in demonstrated in Blasted, the impulse on one hand to demonstrate a certain level of uncomfortable pain to harm also seems connected to the feelings on the other hand to be sat down and bare witness (or be an accomplice at times). There's a general feeling of wanting to reject something that is real in the world, or in the case of theatre, the shadows of the real. Is it the job of the theatre teacher, the pedagogical imperative, to open a window to a world that isn't insulated from violence that, earnestly, we all associate with and contribute to in some capacity? 

Writing this sitrep has left me with more questions about what constitutes playwriting, staging, and performance. It's 8:22 in the evening, a podcast discussing the reception of Sarah Kane's challenging play Blasted is playing where they point to how much Kane's own interview answers; such as Kane arguing theatricality and theatre shouldn't be an evening past time. That it should be difficult. That it should be uncomfortable. That it is painful. Should theatre, and by extension performing as a act, include theatre as entertaining artform with the challenging search for truth? Is stand-up, for example, artful and intellectually challenging enough as an art genre to be something worth studying along side something Arthur Miller wrote in a theatre course?

Note to self: include more comedies (though--really, comedy can be utterly lacerating, no?). Andrew, I would turn your questions more toward pedagogy. Students regularly complain about having to do work or read things that they normally wouldn't read. It's uncomfortable for them, and (I remind myself) it's only natural that they encounter and communicate resistance to experiencing what their brains tell them is unpleasant. How do we as teachers guide them into places of greater resilience? (Do we? Is that our job?)

Emmy asks some juicy questions about agency and women in 'night, Mother and Streetcar (questions that I think would work very well in a class about feminisms in performance--hint, hint):

When thinking about ‘Night Mother (by Marsha Norman) and A Streetcar Named Desire (Tennessee Williams) in relation to one another, I end up with a lot of questions. 
  • What are the requirements for a play to be considered a feminist canonical play? 
    • Out of those requirements, why are these two productions categorized under the same umbrella? 
  • Why does Stella’s (draft version of Streetcar) suicide give her too much agency, but Jessie’s (‘Night Mother) suicide absolve her of her own?
    • WHAT ABOUT THELMA’S AGENCY?!

Emmy also offers some reflection on the lines between theatre and performance studies. I would venture to say that there's a lot more overlap than you might think, Emmy. Most theatre folk, for example, do think of themselves as "telling stories." In my experience, Hopkins black box and School of Theatre shows operate with different conventions and expectations about what "storytelling" might look like.

Ricardo wraps us up with an honest memory of encountering a painful life event and then navigating the expectation that perhaps that pain could/should be used to channel a more "real" performance. 

 I would always go up first in this class, because (to be frank) I was one of the only students who would come prepared. I made sure to come in memorized, with active choices, to really get the most out of my time in front of the professor. I can’t even remember what monologue I did, I just remembered trying to channel all the feelings I had of my grandma in my performance. This monologue fell flat. My strengths have always been more comedic. I've been trying to scratch and claw my way into a serious dramatic role for a while, but people don’t really want to see me as that. I’m sure I did okay, but I definitely didn’t have some ground-breaking THIS is ACTING moment the professor talks about. I just remembered sitting back down and thinking that I would never be enough to please this professor. Loan sharks would’ve had to murder my entire family in front of me to create enough emotion to get some inkling of a satisfactory performance for this teacher. I just sat back down and stayed quiet. I felt like I wasn’t enough, like I was broken because even five hours after receiving the news I had yet to shed a tear for my grandmother. And then, Polly (I am keeping the real name of this student a secret because what happened is a thousand percent not their fault, they were just doing an amazing job) went up. I had worked with Polly before in this department. Polly was, and is still my friend. Polly went up for their turn and did a monologue about a woman confronting their biological father. In the middle of the monologue, my classmate began to weep openly as she pulled out a note from her pocket that her (fake) father had written. By the end of the monologue my classmate was clearly very shaken by the subject matter of the monologue. My professor congratulated them on their performance and commended them for the deep emotional work they had done to achieve this powerful moment of performance. I’ll be the first to acknowledge that they did a great job, but in the moment I just felt this horrible pit in my stomach. If my classmate was able to evoke so much emotion from imaginary circumstances, how was I ever going to be enough for this professor? How would I ever be a real actor? For Christ’s sake, my grandmother who took care of me for years had just died and I couldn’t even muster one tear.

Dude, I remember so many similar kinds of feelings when I was an undergrad, especially the "crying=good acting" equation I had in my brain. Thanks for sharing that, Ricardo. I'm curious what you think of Barrett's rundown of ethical acting training.

Such good stuff, y'all. Thanks.

 

Monday, February 3, 2025

Sitrep Digest 2

 Blog Digest from Sitrep 2!

Ricardo starts us off with an entertaining story of a star encounter (not spoiling which star or what advice they give Ricardo) before turning to a perennial debate in Improv acting circles (as in: even I, an outsider to Improv, have heard about it for decades). Ricardo gets at how Improv--and by extension realistic acting--seems to many mired in the same set of tired paradigms. Ricardo:

Actors are absolutely being pressured to some up with new stuff to sell. The life of an actor is not easy. So, why has this challenge for survival not caused major innovations in the field (especially in the United States, because one could argue for figures like Grotowski and Boal outside of the US as major innovators.) The truth is I don’t know. One could argue that the particularization of different aspects of Stanislavski’s work has created so many different schools of acting that have been so deeply imbued in our culture that there is no way of getting out. Every supposed new form could just be focusing on a different subspecialty of Stanislavski’s work. I don’t know how to push the field forward, I don’t know how to find the exact new thing that will revolutionize the industry. I can only offer a blueprint. [Improviser Deborah] Frances-White’s essay [in The Improv Handbook] ends with the point that “I also think it is past time that we as individuals and groups, regardless of our school of thinking, seriously begin to build on the work that was started by  [Improv theorist-teachers] Johnstone and Close in an intelligent and exciting way; not by creating outlandish new games with no point, not by changing things for the sake of them, but by asking ourselves what we love about improvisation, why it is exciting and interesting to us, and exploring those qualities in performance– and by making more of the wonderful advantage of it being fairly free of commercial constraints. It costs little to do no matter how we do it, so let’s risk trying to do it differently. It might be wonderful.” The progress of acting lies in the love of acting and the willingness to fail for acting. That is the only way we’ll be able to escape the constraints of the ever-present canon of performance practices.

Of course, innovation for innovation's sake isn't necessarily a virtue. Plenty of world performance traditions value preservation and transmission of classical forms over innovation. Sarah references one of these in her Sitrep, bouncing off a key quote from the Gallagher-Ross article, where he frames the Method's goals in terms of "mediations" that "seek to provide access to unmediated reality." Sarah poses an intriguing counter-example:

The creation of a perceptibly unmediated reality, bolstered by conventions like the fourth wall, and the audience's corresponding suspension of disbelief, has become the ideal breeding ground for 'good theatre'. In this new attempt to beat a dead horse into the ground, the idea of an 'unmediated reality' - that sacred space which actors enter to engage in a 'realistic' portrayal of life - reminds me of non-Western performance practices. The hashikakari in Noh theatre serves as (among other things) a transitional path for the performer, whose very self is changed into the spiritual essence of the character they are playing as they make their way from their dressing room to the stage. This transition strikes me as a non-Western form of mediation, where the focus is not the 'realness' of the performance, but on the reality of the spiritual transmutation of the performer into a completely different being. At the risk of comparing apples to oranges, would not this spiritual transformation trump the realness of The Method as explored by Gallagher-Ross? Noh operates under completely different rules which do not adhere to the box-set presuppositions of a fourth-wall or a suspension of disbelief. On the other hand, The Method has serious receipts which are a testament to its effectiveness at creating 'reality' on a stage - mediated or un-mediated by audio-recording devices or video cameras. The creation, perception, and reception of a private reality in a public theatre setting (in America) relies on an implicit understanding that what happens on the stage is sacred but ephemeral - the slap isn't real, even if the tears are. In non-Western theatre settings like Noh, however, the goal (as I understand it), is not to maintain the tension between the public and the private, but to sever it through spiritual transcendence. The 'Implicit presence' in the room is not a recording device, but a shared experience.

Barrett offers a well-articulated corrective to some of the anti-Strasberg-et-al. readings we've seen of late:

In many ways, I’m no apologist for any one acting methodology over another. I’ve never met Lee Strasburg or worked with him directly, so I can neither corroborate nor deny any conversation concerning his character or actions as a pedagogue. What I think I have learned, and hope that I’m successful at in practice, is how to empower acting students to utilize the tools of Stanislavski-based training (including the Method) in ways they can safely control and be equipped to choose when, how, and if they might apply these tools in rehearsal and performance. The reason I think it is important for North American acting students to understand the descendant Stanislavski-based pedagogies is because these students are living and attempting to work in the historical era of realistic acting and its offshoots. Stanislavski and his ideas emerged at a historical theatrical moment in playwriting and performance that captured the modern sensibility, and so far, nothing has legitimately unseated this acting style in contemporary performance. Yes, there are other kinds of non-realistic theatre. I enjoy and am challenged by many of them. Yes, certain forms of realistic performance have become tiresome, cloying even, and yet…the imaginations and expectations of the contemporary theatre audience are still largely in the grasp of realistic theatre, and the powers that control western theatre programming have not moved on from the style of plays and actor performance that Stanislavski and his descendant pedagogues helped to canonize. Until a viable, epoch-making alternative emerges in the historical sense, it is almost unethical not to offer the training tools of Stanislavski’s practitioners to today’s students.

Craig nicely links the two acting articles back to the seminar's meta-topic of canonicity: 

While I am a fan of how these movements changed storytelling and began to allow theatre to represent more than kings, queens, and aristocracy, I continue to be frustrated about the bastardizations of the "Method" or Stanislavsky's original system. Both articles for me highlighted that as teaching artists we canonize for our students what "good acting" and "proper practices" in the theatre or on film sets require. I fear that many artists have been ruined because their resistance to the old school idea that an actor playing sexuality realistically is the only mark of good acting has been labelled as "weak", or "lacking quality". As an actor who has received several different training styles in my career I have come to dislike the "guru" teaching style in which the quality of one's work is filtered through the lens of one teacher, what often happens is that students spend so much time trying to appeal to what the teacher wants that they lose their own artistic voice and forget why they wanted to act in the first place. A teacher should, in the best case, not be forcing students to live up to their expectations of quality work, but rather they should be giving them tools to create work that they are passionate about sharing. 

 Marina refocuses us on another seminar meta-topic, pedagogy:

Acting training is tricky. One of the working hazards is being emotionally available to a character’s circumstances. Learning how to access that vulnerability is different from person to person, and sometimes unresolved trauma can come up, sometimes we hurt our own feelings. That journey needs to be lead by the student. Perhaps, the professor’s responsibility is to be there to remind them it’s all pretend. Perhaps, the professor needs to check in with the students goals. Sometimes students aren’t ready to hear certain notes. I am not sure. Going back to the Acting Styles class [a course in which students learn "period" styles germane to classical genres, e.g., Shakespeare]. These classes reinforce the “canon” by providing training to perform specific playwrights. In my experience, there was no exploration of different acting styles. What if this class gave students an opportunity to explore adjustments needed for naturalism to expressionism and more. SO with these observations in mind here is my updated list of ideas:

  • Find works/plays that I wish someone would have shown me in undergrad
  • Also, find works/stories that challenge or expand my personal aesthetic/identity/experience
  • Stay curious. 
  • Change it up. Don’t stick to the same rotation of plays. 
  • Don’t ignore the “canon”. Be intentional about how I incorporate it into my classroom.
  • Research Acting Methodologies that weren’t started by dead white men or women.
  • Find ways to give students autonomy on their learning journey.
  • Find ways to balance helping students to feel safe and brave enough to be available to their       characters.
  • Be open to change any of these bullet points
  • Be open to add more bullet points.

I will add:

  • I love bullet points
  • There can always be more!

Andrew jumps ahead to a reading for this week, previewing some of Scott Magelssen's observations about the degree to which we expect (want?) actors to suffer: 

The major assumption here, as with any endeavor in life, is that pain is needed for some kind of growth. Facing something you don't want to admit that you've done or think about, exercising to manage your health and body, or even learning something new can be described as pain. As suffering. In an attempt to make suffering not just palatable, but also manageable for the sake of a higher purpose. Would this lesson, shifting towards the audience when it comes to suffering in art, be a consideration that would be beneficial to shift the conversation away of suffering in dramatic works being determined? Exposure to harm is an important conversation to keep, but how much of the pedgagogy of designated harm is placed solely in dynamic between actor and script? Would having a Wizard-behind-the-Curtain approach to the dramatics would help alleviate the growing pains of theatre as a painful endeavor?

I think it's worthwhile to question the pedagogical value of suffering--not just in performance but more broadly. Though growth often involves some discomfort (getting out of comfort zones), I like to believe that pleasure and passion also work as barometers of learning. 

In any case, it was as always a pleasure to read your thoughts. I look forward to reading more!


Sunday, January 26, 2025

Post 2 of 2: Blog digests!

 At this point, I think I have everyone's blog listed on the Blog List for this page. Do explore each other's writing! Your sitreps were wonderful, especially considering I didn't give you much to go on about what to post. Really, I just want these to be somewhat free-form reflections on how the topics from the prior week inform your own ongoing thinking about teaching the things we do (theatre, oral interp, performance studies, other stuff).

I'll provide a bit of a digest here, quoting bits of your work that I found cool. No quote is "the only thing I liked" or even "the thing from your post I liked most." Mostly I just want to put bits of your thoughts in one place so we can see how they interrelate.

Sarah: The idea that a work is 'left-behind' because it is not committed to a textual archive is indicative of the project of modernity and the politics of progressive development at any cost. What if 'leaving behind' is part of the process of embodied performance? What if, in the same way that an actor sheds pieces that will not ultimately serve the 'final' performance, the loss of pieces of a performance is not a loss to the repertoire, but a synthesis which clarifies the repertoire, making it representative of a specific place and time? I am not against the written word, but I think that sometimes it is okay to forget things, or even for things to evolve and resemble nothing of their past iterations. We can't hold on to everything. [Me: I love the notion of performance acts that are intentionally ephemeral. For the go-to theory of emphemerality in performance, you probably want to look at Peggy Phelan's Unmarked: The Politics of Performance. Lots of performance art deals with this topic. For example, see Félix González-Torres's art, such as "Untitled" (Lover Boys). He weighs out toffee candies to his or his friend's exact weights. He was living with AIDS at the time, which in the 80s was mostly a death sentence. Museum-goers were invited to take some candy. As the candy pile dwindled, so too did his weight, until--like him--there was nothing left.

 

Craig: I sit at a place artistically where I do enjoy exploring past, or so called, "canonical works." I think it is important to continually reevaluate the works of the past because we are still influenced by Shakespeare, Miller, Williams, etc. But at the same time I wonder if I am so interested in these works and building my work on their foundations that I am just perpetuating the White Supremacist idea that everything good and intelligent and foundational has its origins in the pen of a white man. I have personally in my playwriting had to divorce myself from these forms and attempted to make my own work that doesn't emulate these canonical artists but their influence is still undeniable. As a professor I wonder how we can look at these works, not as the perfect epitome of what theatre is that we should aspire to, but as play which were popular and have influence on the way the form has evolved. We cannot short change students from common theatrical knowledge just because we don't like the canon, that knowledge is at the basis of a lot of working theatre artists and academics today. So I think that it is imperative to connect students with different writers in conversation with the canonical ones so that their perspective is influenced by more than the established tried and true trends. [This is a great reflection, especially in light of the R and J Project you wrote/directed last year. I think--and most of the students whose responses I read agree--this was a terrific blend of canon and current/personal interests.]

 

Barrett with a cool question: [Andrew and Sara Ahmed’s] comparison of diversity and inclusion efforts to the Sisyphean task brings home a clear point – the impossibility of fully realizing inclusion. True inclusion, played to its end, is simply everything and everyone that exists. And we all know that in the context of societal functioning and the institution of canon, that is an impossibility. It is impossible in the scope of a topic of study, impossible when attempting to incorporate all the viewpoints in a particular classroom in a particular discussion, impossible when designing a course, impossible in the offering of an academic credential, impossible in the trajectory of a scholar’s entire career of learning. And if inclusivity is functionally impossible, and one does not wish to be a nihilist, but rather prefers to throw one’s lot in with Dr. King’s more hopeful long historical arc towards justice (Dr. King’s remembrance was another moment that didn’t receive sufficient attention this past week), how does one proceed? Because in the end we are back to simply determining where the borders of exclusivity are drawn, whether we term this process as “canon,” call it something else, or proceed without a conclusion. Which leads me back to wondering if there is a philosophical/moral case to be made for exclusion?  Is there any possibility of “correctly” arriving at an aesthetically and morally defensible canon? Or if not, is there good to be had in practices of exclusion? [Such good/important questions, especially alongside Marina's blog post about the current anti-DEI backlash.]

 

Andrew asking the big questions (echoed by Sarah in her Snow Day Posts) of what’s a college education/degree for?: I would argue that education cannot be the sole way that a Canon is to either form or to dismantle a Canon, but it can be a way to consider what exist beyond the "syllabi of life". Once the student leaves the class, many end their educational lives, transitioning to a life that only has marginal learning and maybe even marginal resistance to content that the rest of their lives encounter. We need to have students, of any age, inside or outside of their formal institutional education, to want to learn, and to see that experience as ultimately beneficial outside of getting a job. If that happens, Canons don't need to exist, and education can take a step outside of quotas and evaluations. Which will leak down to literary and theatrical canons that are being taught. my hope is to find out my own solution to get there by the end of this semeste. [Me: if you get there--and I hope you do--please share your answer with us!]

 

Ricardo’s entertaining trials with ears: I find that these appeals of performance are things that I do a lot. I’m a big defender of all types of performance/art. I find myself defending things a lot, because of how easy those around me are to disparage art they don’t deem worthy. The biggest one I find myself defending is professional wrestling. With the Royal Rumble (one of WWE’s biggest premium live events) coming up in a week I’ve already started giving people the sell. It’s a very frustrating process (with how these people react, you’d think Macho Man Randy Savage killed their grandma). I immediately get hit with the classic “You know it’s fake.” To which I rebuttal, most pieces of media you consume are fake. By their definition of fake, fiction is fake. Even then, it isn’t fake, it’s predetermined. There is nothing fake about a man jumping from the top rope and landing on another man, you can’t fake momentum. I’m passionate about wrestling because I’m passionate about performance. This is a passion that is needed to push the theatre field forward. An inclusive view of theatre will only make it grow and prosper. [In fact there's a lot of big-name theatre/performance studies scholars who do fun work on professional wrestling, including Eero Lane from our anthology. Sharon Mazer is another one. And an alum of the PhD program, Neal Hebert (now at Grambling State) is about to publish a book co-written by LSU Philosophy prof John Cogburn on the performance/philosophy of pro wrestling. Also, remind me: you've read The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Diety, right?]

 

Emmy: In high school we were required to read canonical works such as “The Great Gatsby”, “Fahrenheit 451”, “Lord of the Flies”, and so on. It is for this reason that the performance of literature is so successful– students come into the class already familiar with the works of literature that they engage with, but they get to experience them in an embodied way. How does an instructor of this particular class effectively put to use the teachings of non canonicity without going against the teachings of oral interpretation/literary adaptation? [Does that question change when you get to be/determine "the teachings of oral interpretation/literary history?]

 

Marina: What I am taking for myself are the following: How has the “canon” affected my aesthetics and training? What of myself have I left behind because of what was omitted from my education? Often in actor training, professors presume I am white, or feel the need to clarify why I am able to speak Spanish, or pigeonhole me into LatinX roles that would not be appropriate to cast me in. It’s been awkward. I long for an acting class where I can be my full self. Perform in Spanish or English or Spanglish. So, what can I do not to perpetuate that with my students? Based on our forum and readings, there isn’t a straightforward answer. But here’s what I want to try:

·      Find works/plays that I wish someone would have shown me in undergrad

·      Also, find works/stories that challenge or expand my personal aesthetic/identity/experience

·      Stay curious. 

·      Change it up. Don’t stick to the same rotation of plays. 

·      Don’t ignore the “canon”. Be intentional about how I incorporate it into my classroom.

·      Research Acting Methodologies that weren’t started by dead white men or women.

·      Be open to change any of these bullet points

·      Be open to add more bullet points.

My big take away is to be flexible, and investigate myself. If academia was an element, it would be earth. It requires a lot of energy and resources to change it. So I can be a little drop of water and erode away at it little by little or flood it if need be. [This looks like the start of a cool manifesto, Marina! Your lament about DEI made me think of this post by one of my favorite academic bloggers, historian Timothy Burke. His argument: we're gonna have to just do a lot of this previously incentivized work ourselves. We should continue to pursue diversity, equity, and inclusion not because we HAVE to but because it's the right thing to do.]

I'm so pleased you're all in this seminar. I can't wait to see you and continue the conversation in person.

Sitreps 6 and 7!

Goodness but I've been neglectful. I've read your sitreps faithfully, but I've not posted a digest. My apologies. If I'm hon...