Blog Digest from Sitrep 2!
Ricardo starts us off with an entertaining story of a star encounter (not spoiling which star or what advice they give Ricardo) before turning to a perennial debate in Improv acting circles (as in: even I, an outsider to Improv, have heard about it for decades). Ricardo gets at how Improv--and by extension realistic acting--seems to many mired in the same set of tired paradigms. Ricardo:
Actors are absolutely being pressured to some up with new stuff to sell. The life of an actor is not easy. So, why has this challenge for survival not caused major innovations in the field (especially in the United States, because one could argue for figures like Grotowski and Boal outside of the US as major innovators.) The truth is I don’t know. One could argue that the particularization of different aspects of Stanislavski’s work has created so many different schools of acting that have been so deeply imbued in our culture that there is no way of getting out. Every supposed new form could just be focusing on a different subspecialty of Stanislavski’s work. I don’t know how to push the field forward, I don’t know how to find the exact new thing that will revolutionize the industry. I can only offer a blueprint. [Improviser Deborah] Frances-White’s essay [in The Improv Handbook] ends with the point that “I also think it is past time that we as individuals and groups, regardless of our school of thinking, seriously begin to build on the work that was started by [Improv theorist-teachers] Johnstone and Close in an intelligent and exciting way; not by creating outlandish new games with no point, not by changing things for the sake of them, but by asking ourselves what we love about improvisation, why it is exciting and interesting to us, and exploring those qualities in performance– and by making more of the wonderful advantage of it being fairly free of commercial constraints. It costs little to do no matter how we do it, so let’s risk trying to do it differently. It might be wonderful.” The progress of acting lies in the love of acting and the willingness to fail for acting. That is the only way we’ll be able to escape the constraints of the ever-present canon of performance practices.
Of course, innovation for innovation's sake isn't necessarily a virtue. Plenty of world performance traditions value preservation and transmission of classical forms over innovation. Sarah references one of these in her Sitrep, bouncing off a key quote from the Gallagher-Ross article, where he frames the Method's goals in terms of "mediations" that "seek to provide access to unmediated reality." Sarah poses an intriguing counter-example:
The creation of a perceptibly unmediated reality, bolstered by conventions like the fourth wall, and the audience's corresponding suspension of disbelief, has become the ideal breeding ground for 'good theatre'. In this new attempt to beat a dead horse into the ground, the idea of an 'unmediated reality' - that sacred space which actors enter to engage in a 'realistic' portrayal of life - reminds me of non-Western performance practices. The hashikakari in Noh theatre serves as (among other things) a transitional path for the performer, whose very self is changed into the spiritual essence of the character they are playing as they make their way from their dressing room to the stage. This transition strikes me as a non-Western form of mediation, where the focus is not the 'realness' of the performance, but on the reality of the spiritual transmutation of the performer into a completely different being. At the risk of comparing apples to oranges, would not this spiritual transformation trump the realness of The Method as explored by Gallagher-Ross? Noh operates under completely different rules which do not adhere to the box-set presuppositions of a fourth-wall or a suspension of disbelief. On the other hand, The Method has serious receipts which are a testament to its effectiveness at creating 'reality' on a stage - mediated or un-mediated by audio-recording devices or video cameras. The creation, perception, and reception of a private reality in a public theatre setting (in America) relies on an implicit understanding that what happens on the stage is sacred but ephemeral - the slap isn't real, even if the tears are. In non-Western theatre settings like Noh, however, the goal (as I understand it), is not to maintain the tension between the public and the private, but to sever it through spiritual transcendence. The 'Implicit presence' in the room is not a recording device, but a shared experience.
Barrett offers a well-articulated corrective to some of the anti-Strasberg-et-al. readings we've seen of late:
In many ways, I’m no apologist for any one acting methodology over another. I’ve never met Lee Strasburg or worked with him directly, so I can neither corroborate nor deny any conversation concerning his character or actions as a pedagogue. What I think I have learned, and hope that I’m successful at in practice, is how to empower acting students to utilize the tools of Stanislavski-based training (including the Method) in ways they can safely control and be equipped to choose when, how, and if they might apply these tools in rehearsal and performance. The reason I think it is important for North American acting students to understand the descendant Stanislavski-based pedagogies is because these students are living and attempting to work in the historical era of realistic acting and its offshoots. Stanislavski and his ideas emerged at a historical theatrical moment in playwriting and performance that captured the modern sensibility, and so far, nothing has legitimately unseated this acting style in contemporary performance. Yes, there are other kinds of non-realistic theatre. I enjoy and am challenged by many of them. Yes, certain forms of realistic performance have become tiresome, cloying even, and yet…the imaginations and expectations of the contemporary theatre audience are still largely in the grasp of realistic theatre, and the powers that control western theatre programming have not moved on from the style of plays and actor performance that Stanislavski and his descendant pedagogues helped to canonize. Until a viable, epoch-making alternative emerges in the historical sense, it is almost unethical not to offer the training tools of Stanislavski’s practitioners to today’s students.
Craig nicely links the two acting articles back to the seminar's meta-topic of canonicity:
While I am a fan of how these movements changed storytelling and began to allow theatre to represent more than kings, queens, and aristocracy, I continue to be frustrated about the bastardizations of the "Method" or Stanislavsky's original system. Both articles for me highlighted that as teaching artists we canonize for our students what "good acting" and "proper practices" in the theatre or on film sets require. I fear that many artists have been ruined because their resistance to the old school idea that an actor playing sexuality realistically is the only mark of good acting has been labelled as "weak", or "lacking quality". As an actor who has received several different training styles in my career I have come to dislike the "guru" teaching style in which the quality of one's work is filtered through the lens of one teacher, what often happens is that students spend so much time trying to appeal to what the teacher wants that they lose their own artistic voice and forget why they wanted to act in the first place. A teacher should, in the best case, not be forcing students to live up to their expectations of quality work, but rather they should be giving them tools to create work that they are passionate about sharing.
Marina refocuses us on another seminar meta-topic, pedagogy:
Acting training is tricky. One of the working hazards is being emotionally available to a character’s circumstances. Learning how to access that vulnerability is different from person to person, and sometimes unresolved trauma can come up, sometimes we hurt our own feelings. That journey needs to be lead by the student. Perhaps, the professor’s responsibility is to be there to remind them it’s all pretend. Perhaps, the professor needs to check in with the students goals. Sometimes students aren’t ready to hear certain notes. I am not sure. Going back to the Acting Styles class [a course in which students learn "period" styles germane to classical genres, e.g., Shakespeare]. These classes reinforce the “canon” by providing training to perform specific playwrights. In my experience, there was no exploration of different acting styles. What if this class gave students an opportunity to explore adjustments needed for naturalism to expressionism and more. SO with these observations in mind here is my updated list of ideas:
- Find works/plays that I wish someone would have shown me in undergrad
- Also, find works/stories that challenge or expand my personal aesthetic/identity/experience
- Stay curious.
- Change it up. Don’t stick to the same rotation of plays.
- Don’t ignore the “canon”. Be intentional about how I incorporate it into my classroom.
- Research Acting Methodologies that weren’t started by dead white men or women.
- Find ways to give students autonomy on their learning journey.
- Find ways to balance helping students to feel safe and brave enough to be available to their characters.
- Be open to change any of these bullet points
- Be open to add more bullet points.
I will add:
- I love bullet points
- There can always be more!
Andrew jumps ahead to a reading for this week, previewing some of Scott Magelssen's observations about the degree to which we expect (want?) actors to suffer:
The major assumption here, as with any endeavor in life, is that pain is needed for some kind of growth. Facing something you don't want to admit that you've done or think about, exercising to manage your health and body, or even learning something new can be described as pain. As suffering. In an attempt to make suffering not just palatable, but also manageable for the sake of a higher purpose. Would this lesson, shifting towards the audience when it comes to suffering in art, be a consideration that would be beneficial to shift the conversation away of suffering in dramatic works being determined? Exposure to harm is an important conversation to keep, but how much of the pedgagogy of designated harm is placed solely in dynamic between actor and script? Would having a Wizard-behind-the-Curtain approach to the dramatics would help alleviate the growing pains of theatre as a painful endeavor?
I think it's worthwhile to question the pedagogical value of suffering--not just in performance but more broadly. Though growth often involves some discomfort (getting out of comfort zones), I like to believe that pleasure and passion also work as barometers of learning.
In any case, it was as always a pleasure to read your thoughts. I look forward to reading more!
No comments:
Post a Comment