Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Sitrep Post 3

 As always, it's a pleasure to read your thoughts on our prior week. I encourage you all to peruse each others' blogs when you can.

To whet your appetites, here's you weekly digest:

Barrett shares his thoughts on ethical, care-based actor training. Having taught acting in a conservatory environment for several years, he knows whereof he speaks, and he says it well:

To treat emotion work like any other facet of acting training, the topic of emotion needs to be further demystified. This starts by acknowledging exactly what is likely to happen to the actor when working with emotion, what the norms of experience are for actors during this part of the training, what constitutes a healthy and unhealthy range of experiences that one might have as they participate in this work, and offering a series of ways for students to process, discuss, and seek help with their experiences as they occur. Central in this discussion is an explanation of how emotions work, and crucially, why they matter in acting. Magelssen’s article stresses only one aim for emotional work, and while it is true that utilizing lived emotions contributes to the overall truthfulness of realistic performance, isolating emotions in acting training for the goal of “being more real” is an incomplete, and as the article makes clear, dangerous pedagogical practice. Emotions in acting should never be sought as an end result. Magelssen unfortunately neglects to point out that 21st-century students are generally called upon to perform objective-based work, and that emotions are useful because they are motivators of human action. Acting pedagogy cultivates students’ ability to access a wide range of emotion in order to further their ability to take action in a truthful manner. Emotions are simply an engine to drive behavior, which is the ultimate aim of the realistic actor. Any other use of emotion is self-indulgent, resulting in anti-dramatic work in the Aristotelian sense. Possessing this knowledge empowers actors to gauge their performance not on the strength of their overall emotional largesse. It allows them to regulate the use of emotion in performance by comparing it to what is essential at any given moment to achieve their truthful expression of an objective.

 If you're anything like me, I bet you find yourself a bit envious of Barrett's acting students. Barrett--were you yourself taught acting this way? Or did you find a better way than you were taught?

I love how Craig opens himself to surprise and curiosity by engaging Streetcar after years of resisting it (we all have plays/works/books we resist for some reason): 

I was surprised to discover that the play was about Blanche trying to find agency rather than being a portrait of Stanley Kowalski as an abuser. Stanley's abusiveness is apart of the puzzle, but not the sole focus of the piece. This discovery has led me to question why the play and subsequent Elia Kazan film are so remembered for Stanley and for Brando's performance as opposed to being remembered as a story about a woman trying to find agency and being held back by a patriarchal society. Critically it seems that the play is remembered for Brando's performance to the point that Blanche's story is forgotten. This is a moment where, similarly to our reading of 'night mother it seems that critical consensus missed the seeming intentions of Williams' text. The play was overwhelmed by the performance text created by Kazan, Brando, and the original cast.

One of the best things that can happen in a class like this (or any class), I think, is for us to be surprised out of our preconceptions about things we think we know. I really appreciate your sharing this, Craig.

Marina gives us an excellent example of a pedagogy of care done well:

Before I came to LSU, I taught for many years as a Teaching Artist. I received countless hours of training in Theatre of the Oppressed techniques/exercises, non-violent communication, and student-centered practices. In our pedagogy class at LSU, we did not receive any training in these areas. So, it appears to me that the ethics of care is not a priority at LSU. Or, it is only a priority for certain professors. In turn, students are receiving an “imbalance of care.” As a teaching artist, I always started my semester by asking students to come up with their community agreements. This practice was important for students to be invested in the entire groups well-being and progress. Since teaching here, I have abandoned that practice in exchange for a syllabus. A syllabus that I alone create. I have been operating this way because it is what was modeled for me. But after reading this article, I am recognizing I want to bring more of my teaching artist self into academic classes. For instance, I am in Kyla’s mask making class. For our first two days of class, she opened the floor for students to shape the syllabus and community agreements. I did not know I could do that. There were some non-negotiables, but she communicated why they were necessary.

Kyla Kazuschyk, for the record, is one of our best teachers. Your reflection, Marina, reminded me of the care article's quote about "care" consisting of "uncoerced choice" (or something like that). Kyla's open-syllabus assignment models that well.

In light of the violence in--well, all the plays we've read so far (especially this week), Andrew asks some provocative questions:

From A Street Car Named Desire to Belle Reprieve, or the violence in demonstrated in Blasted, the impulse on one hand to demonstrate a certain level of uncomfortable pain to harm also seems connected to the feelings on the other hand to be sat down and bare witness (or be an accomplice at times). There's a general feeling of wanting to reject something that is real in the world, or in the case of theatre, the shadows of the real. Is it the job of the theatre teacher, the pedagogical imperative, to open a window to a world that isn't insulated from violence that, earnestly, we all associate with and contribute to in some capacity? 

Writing this sitrep has left me with more questions about what constitutes playwriting, staging, and performance. It's 8:22 in the evening, a podcast discussing the reception of Sarah Kane's challenging play Blasted is playing where they point to how much Kane's own interview answers; such as Kane arguing theatricality and theatre shouldn't be an evening past time. That it should be difficult. That it should be uncomfortable. That it is painful. Should theatre, and by extension performing as a act, include theatre as entertaining artform with the challenging search for truth? Is stand-up, for example, artful and intellectually challenging enough as an art genre to be something worth studying along side something Arthur Miller wrote in a theatre course?

Note to self: include more comedies (though--really, comedy can be utterly lacerating, no?). Andrew, I would turn your questions more toward pedagogy. Students regularly complain about having to do work or read things that they normally wouldn't read. It's uncomfortable for them, and (I remind myself) it's only natural that they encounter and communicate resistance to experiencing what their brains tell them is unpleasant. How do we as teachers guide them into places of greater resilience? (Do we? Is that our job?)

Emmy asks some juicy questions about agency and women in 'night, Mother and Streetcar (questions that I think would work very well in a class about feminisms in performance--hint, hint):

When thinking about ‘Night Mother (by Marsha Norman) and A Streetcar Named Desire (Tennessee Williams) in relation to one another, I end up with a lot of questions. 
  • What are the requirements for a play to be considered a feminist canonical play? 
    • Out of those requirements, why are these two productions categorized under the same umbrella? 
  • Why does Stella’s (draft version of Streetcar) suicide give her too much agency, but Jessie’s (‘Night Mother) suicide absolve her of her own?
    • WHAT ABOUT THELMA’S AGENCY?!

Emmy also offers some reflection on the lines between theatre and performance studies. I would venture to say that there's a lot more overlap than you might think, Emmy. Most theatre folk, for example, do think of themselves as "telling stories." In my experience, Hopkins black box and School of Theatre shows operate with different conventions and expectations about what "storytelling" might look like.

Ricardo wraps us up with an honest memory of encountering a painful life event and then navigating the expectation that perhaps that pain could/should be used to channel a more "real" performance. 

 I would always go up first in this class, because (to be frank) I was one of the only students who would come prepared. I made sure to come in memorized, with active choices, to really get the most out of my time in front of the professor. I can’t even remember what monologue I did, I just remembered trying to channel all the feelings I had of my grandma in my performance. This monologue fell flat. My strengths have always been more comedic. I've been trying to scratch and claw my way into a serious dramatic role for a while, but people don’t really want to see me as that. I’m sure I did okay, but I definitely didn’t have some ground-breaking THIS is ACTING moment the professor talks about. I just remembered sitting back down and thinking that I would never be enough to please this professor. Loan sharks would’ve had to murder my entire family in front of me to create enough emotion to get some inkling of a satisfactory performance for this teacher. I just sat back down and stayed quiet. I felt like I wasn’t enough, like I was broken because even five hours after receiving the news I had yet to shed a tear for my grandmother. And then, Polly (I am keeping the real name of this student a secret because what happened is a thousand percent not their fault, they were just doing an amazing job) went up. I had worked with Polly before in this department. Polly was, and is still my friend. Polly went up for their turn and did a monologue about a woman confronting their biological father. In the middle of the monologue, my classmate began to weep openly as she pulled out a note from her pocket that her (fake) father had written. By the end of the monologue my classmate was clearly very shaken by the subject matter of the monologue. My professor congratulated them on their performance and commended them for the deep emotional work they had done to achieve this powerful moment of performance. I’ll be the first to acknowledge that they did a great job, but in the moment I just felt this horrible pit in my stomach. If my classmate was able to evoke so much emotion from imaginary circumstances, how was I ever going to be enough for this professor? How would I ever be a real actor? For Christ’s sake, my grandmother who took care of me for years had just died and I couldn’t even muster one tear.

Dude, I remember so many similar kinds of feelings when I was an undergrad, especially the "crying=good acting" equation I had in my brain. Thanks for sharing that, Ricardo. I'm curious what you think of Barrett's rundown of ethical acting training.

Such good stuff, y'all. Thanks.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Sitreps 6 and 7!

Goodness but I've been neglectful. I've read your sitreps faithfully, but I've not posted a digest. My apologies. If I'm hon...