Hey, all!
First, thanks for hanging on and participating in our pivot to the Moodle Forum, and thanks also for doing the first Sitrep posts on your blogs! Do take a look at your classmates' posts. I think you'll see how Great Minds are thinking alike here.
For tomorrow (Monday, Jan 27), we're all reading 'night, Mother and the second chapter of Dolan's foundational text, The Feminist Spectator as Critic, where she talks about that play and its reception.
A few quick backgrounders that might help as you process that chapter:
Three Feminisms: In Dolan's first chapter (I'll post that on moodle as optional background), she lays out a (really clear, really influential for its time) three-part taxonomy of feminist traditions: liberal feminism, cultural feminism, and materialist feminism. You should read her own take on those, but the TL;DR is as follows:
- Liberal feminism responds to the problem of sexist inequality/oppression by seeking to make extant systems (institutions, canons, seasons, etc.) equal in terms of men and women. The assumption here is that equalizing men and women at all levels will result in more equitable and less sexist institutions. (Dolan is writing before more gender-expansive modalities of identity were widely known/talked about.)
- Cultural feminism (aka radical feminism) responds to the problem of sexist inequality/oppression by proposing separatism--a wholly distinct culture of/by/for women. Key here would be distinguishing "male" and "female" aesthetics, privileging exploration and expression of the latter. The assumption is that women can't know what "feminist art/theatre/institutions" would even be within a context of misogyny and sexism. They need separate institutions.
- Materialist feminism ("materialist" in the Cold War 70s and 80s was often code for "Marxist" or "Marxism-inflected") suggests that sexism and inequality are built into and reproduced by institutions themselves. Fixing sexism thus requires fixing/redesigning institutions.
There's a bit of the Goldilocks trope going on--Dolon strongly leans toward materialist. To her credit, though, Dolan recognizes that all three streams have strengths, and she admits to having more liberal, cultural, and materialist moments/tendencies. They aren't absolute distinctions, after all, but just a way of thinking about 1980s feminism. She's revisited this taxonomy since then in subsequent articles.
The Unities: The other thing she refers to here that might need tying down: "Aristotelian unities." So: as you may know, Aristotle (300s BCE) wrote The Poetics, his treatise (or loose collection of lecture notes) about tragic dramatic poetry. ("I'll write about comedy later," he says, but we don't have that writing.) He's mainly concerned with description, inventing the wheel of defining tragic dramatic poetry as different from, but equally worthy of study to, epic poetry.
Later critics--especially in the Renaissance, especially in the French Neoclassical era (1600s)--sort of took Aristotle, combined him with bits of Horace (a Roman poet/critic writing about drama), and created a set of standards for what "good theatre" was. Somewhat like fundamentalist Christians creating whole doctrines out of scraps of (or creative readings of) scripture, these critics established "the Aristotelian Unities": The unity of time (plots should equal stage time, or at least not represent longer than a single day), the unity of place (plots should be set in only one location), and the unity of action (no "double plots"--like two storylines that ultimately join). Important: Aristotle doesn't talk about the unities per se. They're attributed to him, but they aren't him.
There were other aspects of this Neoclassical Ideal that stuck around--decorum (characters should act true to their proper status--no mad/bad kings, no noble servants), poetic justice (good need to be rewarded, bad punished), and genre distinction (no mixing of comedy/tragedy/pastoral)--but "the unities" remained most influential. Also: for most of Western theatre history, the comedy/tragedy distinction had to do more with the class status of the protagonist. Tragedies were by nature about higher sorts of people (kings, queens, rulers, folk you don't laugh at), and comedies were about lower sorts of people (servants, pretenders to nobility, folk worthy of being laughed at).
After a period of intensely Neoclassical drama (drama that followed "the rules"), pretty much every European theatrical movement after that was either a reaction to Neoclassicism (e.g., Romanticism), or a reaction to the reaction, or a reaction to the reaction to the reaction, etc. It's just embedded itself into Western dramaturgical DNA.
I'm eager to hear what you think of 'night, Mother--a truly ubiquitous text when I was in high school/undergrad. It's solidly canonical. Dolan has become one of the most influential scholars in our field, continuing to write lots of conversation-changing works. It helps that she's also one of the most thoroughly generous, wonderful, and thoughtful people you'll ever meet.
Now on to blog posts!
John