At this point, I think I have everyone's blog listed on the Blog List for this page. Do explore each other's writing! Your sitreps were wonderful, especially considering I didn't give you much to go on about what to post. Really, I just want these to be somewhat free-form reflections on how the topics from the prior week inform your own ongoing thinking about teaching the things we do (theatre, oral interp, performance studies, other stuff).
I'll provide a bit of a digest here, quoting bits of your work that I found cool. No quote is "the only thing I liked" or even "the thing from your post I liked most." Mostly I just want to put bits of your thoughts in one place so we can see how they interrelate.
Sarah: The idea that a work is 'left-behind' because it is not committed to a textual archive is indicative of the project of modernity and the politics of progressive development at any cost. What if 'leaving behind' is part of the process of embodied performance? What if, in the same way that an actor sheds pieces that will not ultimately serve the 'final' performance, the loss of pieces of a performance is not a loss to the repertoire, but a synthesis which clarifies the repertoire, making it representative of a specific place and time? I am not against the written word, but I think that sometimes it is okay to forget things, or even for things to evolve and resemble nothing of their past iterations. We can't hold on to everything. [Me: I love the notion of performance acts that are intentionally ephemeral. For the go-to theory of emphemerality in performance, you probably want to look at Peggy Phelan's Unmarked: The Politics of Performance. Lots of performance art deals with this topic. For example, see Félix González-Torres's art, such as "Untitled" (Lover Boys). He weighs out toffee candies to his or his friend's exact weights. He was living with AIDS at the time, which in the 80s was mostly a death sentence. Museum-goers were invited to take some candy. As the candy pile dwindled, so too did his weight, until--like him--there was nothing left.
Craig: I sit at a place artistically where I do enjoy
exploring past, or so called, "canonical works." I think it is
important to continually reevaluate the works of the past because we are still
influenced by Shakespeare, Miller, Williams, etc. But at the same time I wonder
if I am so interested in these works and building my work on their foundations
that I am just perpetuating the White Supremacist idea that everything good and
intelligent and foundational has its origins in the pen of a white man. I have
personally in my playwriting had to divorce myself from these forms and
attempted to make my own work that doesn't emulate these canonical artists but
their influence is still undeniable. As a professor I wonder how we can look at
these works, not as the perfect epitome of what theatre is that we should
aspire to, but as play which were popular and have influence on the way the
form has evolved. We cannot short change students from common theatrical
knowledge just because we don't like the canon, that knowledge is at the basis
of a lot of working theatre artists and academics today. So I think that it is
imperative to connect students with different writers in conversation with the
canonical ones so that their perspective is influenced by more than the
established tried and true trends. [This is a great reflection, especially in light of the R and J Project you wrote/directed last year. I think--and most of the students whose responses I read agree--this was a terrific blend of canon and current/personal interests.]
Barrett with a cool question: [Andrew and Sara Ahmed’s] comparison
of diversity and inclusion efforts to the Sisyphean task brings home a clear
point – the impossibility of fully realizing inclusion. True inclusion, played
to its end, is simply everything and everyone that exists. And we all know that
in the context of societal functioning and the institution of canon, that is an
impossibility. It is impossible in the scope of a topic of study, impossible
when attempting to incorporate all the viewpoints in a particular classroom in
a particular discussion, impossible when designing a course, impossible in the
offering of an academic credential, impossible in the trajectory of a scholar’s
entire career of learning. And if inclusivity is functionally impossible, and
one does not wish to be a nihilist, but rather prefers to throw one’s lot in
with Dr. King’s more hopeful long historical arc towards justice (Dr. King’s
remembrance was another moment that didn’t receive sufficient attention this
past week), how does one proceed? Because in the end we are back to simply
determining where the borders of exclusivity are drawn, whether we term this
process as “canon,” call it something else, or proceed without a conclusion.
Which leads me back to wondering if there is a philosophical/moral case to be
made for exclusion? Is there any
possibility of “correctly” arriving at an aesthetically and morally defensible
canon? Or if not, is there good to be had in practices of exclusion? [Such good/important questions, especially alongside Marina's blog post about the current anti-DEI backlash.]
Andrew asking the big questions (echoed by Sarah in her Snow Day Posts) of what’s a college education/degree for?: I would argue that education cannot be the sole way that a Canon is to either form or to dismantle a Canon, but it can be a way to consider what exist beyond the "syllabi of life". Once the student leaves the class, many end their educational lives, transitioning to a life that only has marginal learning and maybe even marginal resistance to content that the rest of their lives encounter. We need to have students, of any age, inside or outside of their formal institutional education, to want to learn, and to see that experience as ultimately beneficial outside of getting a job. If that happens, Canons don't need to exist, and education can take a step outside of quotas and evaluations. Which will leak down to literary and theatrical canons that are being taught. my hope is to find out my own solution to get there by the end of this semeste. [Me: if you get there--and I hope you do--please share your answer with us!]
Ricardo’s entertaining trials with ears: I find that these
appeals of performance are things that I do a lot. I’m a big defender of all
types of performance/art. I find myself defending things a lot, because of how
easy those around me are to disparage art they don’t deem worthy. The biggest
one I find myself defending is professional wrestling. With the Royal Rumble
(one of WWE’s biggest premium live events) coming up in a week I’ve already
started giving people the sell. It’s a very frustrating process (with how these
people react, you’d think Macho Man Randy Savage killed their grandma). I
immediately get hit with the classic “You know it’s fake.” To which I rebuttal,
most pieces of media you consume are fake. By their definition of fake, fiction
is fake. Even then, it isn’t fake, it’s predetermined. There is nothing fake
about a man jumping from the top rope and landing on another man, you can’t
fake momentum. I’m passionate about wrestling because I’m passionate about
performance. This is a passion that is needed to push the theatre field forward.
An inclusive view of theatre will only make it grow and prosper. [In fact there's a lot of big-name theatre/performance studies scholars who do fun work on professional wrestling, including Eero Lane from our anthology. Sharon Mazer is another one. And an alum of the PhD program, Neal Hebert (now at Grambling State) is about to publish a book co-written by LSU Philosophy prof John Cogburn on the performance/philosophy of pro wrestling. Also, remind me: you've read The Elaborate Entrance of Chad Diety, right?]
Emmy: In high school we were required to read canonical
works such as “The Great Gatsby”, “Fahrenheit 451”, “Lord of the Flies”, and so
on. It is for this reason that the performance of literature is so successful–
students come into the class already familiar with the works of literature that
they engage with, but they get to experience them in an embodied
way. How does an instructor of this particular class effectively put to use the
teachings of non canonicity without going against the teachings of oral
interpretation/literary adaptation? [Does that question change when you get to be/determine "the teachings of oral interpretation/literary history?]
Marina: What I am taking for myself are the following: How has the “canon” affected my aesthetics and training? What of myself have I left behind because of what was omitted from my education? Often in actor training, professors presume I am white, or feel the need to clarify why I am able to speak Spanish, or pigeonhole me into LatinX roles that would not be appropriate to cast me in. It’s been awkward. I long for an acting class where I can be my full self. Perform in Spanish or English or Spanglish. So, what can I do not to perpetuate that with my students? Based on our forum and readings, there isn’t a straightforward answer. But here’s what I want to try:
· Find works/plays that I wish someone would have shown me in undergrad
· Also, find works/stories that challenge or expand my personal aesthetic/identity/experience
· Stay curious.
· Change it up. Don’t stick to the same rotation of plays.
· Don’t ignore the “canon”. Be intentional about how I incorporate it into my classroom.
· Research Acting Methodologies that weren’t started by dead white men or women.
· Be open to change any of these bullet points
· Be open to add more bullet points.
My big take away is to be flexible, and investigate
myself. If academia was an element, it would be earth. It requires a lot of
energy and resources to change it. So I can be a little drop of water and erode
away at it little by little or flood it if need be. [This looks like the start of a cool manifesto, Marina! Your lament about DEI made me think of this post by one of my favorite academic bloggers, historian Timothy Burke. His argument: we're gonna have to just do a lot of this previously incentivized work ourselves. We should continue to pursue diversity, equity, and inclusion not because we HAVE to but because it's the right thing to do.]
I'm so pleased you're all in this seminar. I can't wait to see you and continue the conversation in person.
No comments:
Post a Comment