Let's start with Andrew, who picks up on Colbert's commentary on Wine in the Wilderness and links (intersects?) it with Kemberle Crenshaw's work:
We see in the play how much class distinctions is intentional made early on. According to Colbert (2009), "In teaching this play, I direct my students’ attention to how the characters’ language suggests their class positioning. I question how Bill’s class-inflected speech differs and aligns with Tommy’s categorization of her neighbors. I alert students to the fact that Tommy’s use of the pejorative separates her from the rioters and establishes her behavior as one of the several demarcations of class differences within the play. While most readings of Wine in the Wilderness, including La Vinia Delois Jennings’s account in Alice Childress, consider the ways Tommy forces Bill, Sonny-Man, and Cynthia to acknowledge their class privilege, critics do not consider Tommy’s assertions of superiority, which reveal a third class at play—the rioters. Moreover, since Riot Sale and The Bronx Is Next depict characters participating in or planning a riot, these plays do not establish the layers of divisions presented in Childress’s."
This line of thinking marks similar will Kimberlee Crenshaws paper, "Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color", we see how in pushing one side of a left leaning argument, it fails towards liberation for all and more aligns closely with liberation for all with caveats. Liberation is impeded not only by those how those traditionally in power resists and demand the status quo preserved, but it is also impeded at times by those trying to do revolutionary work. This is colonial though process makes it difficult for for consolidation. The play, as Colbert demonstrates, shows divisions among seemingly similar groups of people because of colonial Eurocentric views about mobility, and even notions of freedom and liberation.
Plays like this help demonstrate better the widening gap in groups that are labeled as "monolithic", because the classist nature of some in the group positions themselves as being the ones to pull up the rest of their ethnic group, while the the other gets the arm dragged and forced to be something they don't want to be. The play demonstrates this well in this and any community that seems divided amongst themselves, mainly because class is always obfuscated. Made hard to see. That way when a person like Tommy comes into a scene, we can blame their life being the way it is as "her fault", or show some kind of self-aggrandizing pity without actively changing anything about our own lives to make hers marginally better.
Echoing some of these themes--how certain strands of liberatory rhetoric work by suppressing other strands--Sarah gives us a banger of a post with some some trenchant questions about other kinds of suppressed rhetorics (and identities):
Towards the end of the play, Tommy has a phenomenal moment in the sun: raging against Bill, Old Timer, Sonny-Man, and Cynthia, she demonstrates the deep seated self-loathing at the heart of their progressive ethos. She strikes them in the same way that a mother would - with accuracy, care, and the intent to build up. While she calls them out for the way they abused her trust and misaligned her character, she also opens their eyes to reality of their societal position, demonstrating the ways in which the superiority they claimed was only functioning to reinforce the very negative stereotypes they were trying to escape.
But right at the moment of Tommy's triumph, something strange occurs. She opens Bill's eyes to his rather misogynistic view of black women, showing that her living, breathing, existence was so much more than one simple swipe on a canvas. At this moment, Bill comes to the realisation that Tommy is right, and he promptly takes control of the reigns. Just as Tommy is about to triumphantly exit the space and leave the group to their collective shame, Bill pipes up and begins to wax poetic. The very first thing that he does is reorient the identities of the people around him - identities which, up until this point, were depicted as being inferior to his masculine, nationalistic, virile, artistic prowess. First, he reinforces Old Timer by using his real name (a name he was not aware of prior to Tommy's arrival). He then confronts Cynthia with the truth of her beauty, and makes an interesting rhetorical gesture by immediately linking it with Sonny-Man's masculinity. Tommy's exit is interrupted by Bill's apparent enlightenment, and the woman who was adamantly against posing in a mis-matched outfit is convinced to pose, holding the wig that was initially so abhorrent to Bill. The final line of the show (like the first one), is given to Bill, who engages in the artistic practise of composing a black female identity that is bolstered by an appeased black masculinity.
This is worth at least a conference paper, Sarah, if not a (part of) an article. You'd want to do some more poking around to see if someone else has noted this as well (Colbert would be a good place to start, I think). But yes: great.
And I appreciate Craig fighting through the after-show fog to comment thoughtfully on last week's readings:
Alice Childress' Wine in the Wilderness, got me really excited to examine the way that Blackness, particularly Black Femininity, is presented in theatre. The battle for Blackness and its representation on stage is one that is obviously compelling for me. When thinking about how to help students engage with works by Black artists I think it is imperative that we try to remind students that the culture is not monolithic and contains just as much variance as any other. Setting Raisin and Wine against each other, in terms of comparison, is a good step in the right direction because of the combination of works. I'm very interested in pedagogy that puts plays in comparison with one another to understand a canonical work, and another lesser known work from the period. In an undergraduate classroom I am concerned with the amount of bandwidth that students will have to read so many works in order to accomplish the curriculum. Even as a Graduate student I am finding the reading difficult to keep up with among my other responsibilities. So the question is how can we get students to engage with multiple works while not burning them out?
I hear (and echo!) Craig's crowded-bandwidth feelings. Realize how stressed you are reading plays for this class (let alone plays and articles). Mark that level of stress--and our inevitable reactions to stress (i.e., skimming, not reading and just feeling really guilty, promising ourselves we'll read them later, etc.). Let that inform your own decisions as you start thinking about the first syllabus you'll put together and present (on Wednesday, March 19!). Less really is more. But! Comparing two plays is super-valuable! What to do?
Emmy steers us back to Raisin in the Sun in the first part of her post:
Interesting to compare it to communism, marxism, ect, because that’s the last thing I would expect in reference to an analysis of this play. I would expect, however, conversations based around racial and gender inequality. . . but the more I think about it (and think about the definition of communism– EQUALITY) the more I realize it’s not so crazy of an idea to look at this story through this particular lens.
But in thinking through the lens of communism and equality, it was extremely unfair in Beneatha’s circumstance wherein she lost all of her money for med school. Where is the justice for her? Running off to Africa with Asagai?You know what, Emmy? You're right: Hansberry is so focused on Walter's deferred dream that she gives short shrift to Beneatha and her dream. When does Beneatha get her own play? I bet it's been done. There's even a whole anthology about plays based on or spinning off from Raisin. [Quick duckduckgo-ing] Bingo! Beneatha's Place by Kwame Kwei-Armah. (Production poster to the left) I don't know how to get a copy. Perhaps you could write him and ask!
Speaking of which: Ricardo builds on his presentation about TikTok to affirm another affordance of social mediatized culture: reciprocity between artists and audiences:
In the presentation I made on Wednesday’s class I talked about social media’s (more specifically, tiktok’s) ability to reach out to younger audiences and find more people to fill up seats, but what I didn’t touch upon was the inverse effect of all these shows and people having a social media presence. People you admire are easier to reach out now than they ever were, before you would have to write them a letter and hope they would get back to you, but nowadays you can just send them a silly little text on the device you’re already on for most of your day. I have used this to my advantage. Most of the time, playwrights are very willing to share their work that isn’t readily available if you just ask nicely. A couple months ago, I saw that Playwright Horizons was putting on a show titled In the Amazon Warehouse Parking Lot. I knew nothing about this play, other than the title and a short trailer posted on their Youtube channel, but I couldn’t help how badly I wanted to read it. I looked it up online to see if I could purchase it anywhere, but I was out of luck. Parking Lot is still in production and hasn’t reached its final version just yet. I thought that would be it, until the thought came to mind to follow and message the playwright. I just messaged Sarah Mantell “Hi, I love reading plays and I really wanted to read In the Amazon Warehouse Parking Lot. How can I find it?” She responded within two days with her personal email and shared the most updated version of the script with me. It was awesome. I’ve been doing this for some time now. Whenever I can’t find a play I’ll follow the writer on social media and just message them. I haven’t been ignored once, playwrights really want to share their work and if you show them how much you appreciate it they’ll be very happy to share.
Marina gives a great overview of all the work from last week (I confess I had forgotten that Polanski directed the movie adaptation of Death and the Maiden). Here she weighs in on the social media reciprocity referenced above:
I’m Gonna Marry You, Toby Maguire was a fun read! I am intrigued by the similacrum play. If I was going to put this play in my syllabi, I would want to include an article to help students understand what Hurley is doing. I am still wrapping my brain around what Hurley is doing. Also, I think Ricardo connections to social media and engagement are interesting. Working in the Swine Palace office, I have little bandwidth or curiosity to strategize impactful social media campaigns. I was hoping I would learn from someone, but it is a fend for yourself kinda vibe. Theatre is hurting for audiences, and I think many companies focus their efforts on how to get “subscribers” aka senior citizens back. But, if theatre wants to stay relevant, we need to pay attention to what gets young people excited about coming to the theatre.
But, as Barrett explores in his post, promising social media affordances do not come without price. Here he writes about "cashing in on FOMO":
The second phrase that was spoken in class and stuck out to me this week, is perhaps the flip side of social media. In the rush to be on trend and capitalize on markets that others are successfully exploiting, I do wonder about the ethics of “cashing in on FOMO.” It’s now pretty widely known that social media is creating addicts and at least contributing to such serious mental health issues like anxiety, anti-social behaviors, and even suicide (see here: NIH). Before we anoint the next generation of TikTok Dramaturgs, should we at least ask the question if “cashing on FOMO” is aligned with any kind of personal or company values? Thomas Davenport and Jeanne Harris in their article “What People Want (And How to Predict It)” state what we all know to be true about human behavior: “As soon as it’s clear that money can be made using these…tools, their use will undoubtedly grow despite some observers’ moral and ethical qualms.” Yet much of the discussion we’ve been having as a class - care of actors, care of students, what to teach, what kinds of representation should be included in our canon – these are ethical and moral conversations. Anecdotally, I feel like the variety and frequency of ethical discussions in theatrical praxis has risen greatly since I’ve been a practicing theatre maker. Perhaps because of that when Ricardo described TikTok as having the most successful social media algorithm to keep folks scrolling and lose track of time, it gave me pause. How fast, I wonder, should theatre producers be rushing to “cash in” on people’s addictions? Is there a moral conversation to be had here about what this kind of marketing is doing to our potential customers, or if one were so inclined to view them more personally, our community members?
(The Hnath play you reference sounds fabulous, Barrett.)
As always, everyone, excellent posts.
Now I'm off to speed-re-read Guirgis and Ybarra (and first-time-read the article about Guirgis) for tomorrow's class. After all, I would hate to listen to a stimulating conversation and feel . . . FOMO.

No comments:
Post a Comment